Indigo Edina (Chair & Spokesperson for North West England)
Throughout the last decade, Green movements have made real headway in Western politics. From climate change to social justice, these movements have had an outsized role in shaping the agenda on crucial policy areas. The solutions greens propose, such as Net Zero carbon emissions and greater investment in public transport, have caught fire with a certain type of urban progressive voter. Given the scope of these proposals, any plausible path to their implementation would, however, require a foray into territory less familiar to green politics: political economy.
Beyond a commitment to environmental sustainability and human need, greens have historically lacked a cohesive theory of how the economy should be organised. Consequently, different greens have reached varied conclusions as to how our movement should go about financing our ambitions. Reformists desire progressive capitalism to facilitate good growth which can be taxed for public investment. Ecosocialists want to recalibrate the economy around common ownership to put people and planet first. And as of late, Modern Monetary Theory has been proposed as a means to raise the necessary capital for the green transition. Given the growing influence of this persuasion over leftist discourse, especially in the Green Party of England and Wales, I wish to dedicate an article to discussing what this theory is, why I believe it to be deficient, and outline a ‘geosocialist’ alternative rooted in left-libertarian ideas.
I: Summarising Modern Monetary Theory
Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) emerged in the early 21st Century (though it can trace the genesis of some core claims back a century) from heterodox post-Keynesian economic thought. It has gained international popularity as of late due its promotion by some economists to the general public, with the release of books such as Stephanie Kelton’s The Deficit Myth among others. With quite fundamental changes in the global economy from the mid 20th Century onwards, including the abandonment of the gold standard and deindustrialisation, MMT argues that many economists are stuck in the past and refuse to accept the new material realities of the world economy.conomy.
The main claim of Modern Monetary Theory is that the traditional narrative of tax and spend is wrong. Rather than governments relying on tax revenue for day-to-day spending, MMT argues that states with monetary sovereignty (i.e. their own currency) can credit institutions with near impunity, given that they will never have to default on their debts. Taxation, in this framework, is only necessary for holding down inflation and inducing demand in the otherwise worthless fiat currency. Consequently, MMT rejects the narrative often propagated by the right that governments need to spend within their means in favour of simply creating the funds necessary for their desired policies within the scope of real economic capacity. To achieve this, the independence of the central bank would be suspended and interest rates would cease to be the main means by which inflation rates are controlled. In short, MMT argues that the evolution of the world economy since WW2 allows states with monetary sovereignty to be far more flexible with their fiscal and monetary policies than orthodox economics recognises.
While not committed to many specific policy proposals beyond this theoretical core, MMT supporters are generally inclined to oppose austerity in favour of high public spending on broadly Keynesian grounds. The purpose of flexible monetary policy is usually the financing of the very public projects greens wish to pursue. The idea that we already have the means to afford the green transition and other left-populist policies is, unsurprisingly, seductive to activists and politicians alike. As leader of the Green Party of England and Wales, Zack Polanski has engaged with MMT theorists like Richard Murphy. In America, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has argued that MMT should play a larger role in shaping future US monetary policy. Thus, this theory is often used as the basis for left-wing populists to lend credibility for their populist slogans.
II: The Flaws of Modern Monetary Theory
However novel the insights of MMT may be, the framework (especially as it is proposed by its advocates) has several major problems. The first of which is less of a problem with the theory itself, and more from the way its activists promote the theory. It is not uncommon for popular discourse to reduce MMT down to the claim that governments can pursue fiscal expansionism without consequence, and that no deficit is too high. The theory itself does not make this claim, arguing that governments remain limited by economic capacity and inflation. Yet this has not stopped activists and politicians from citing MMT as a justification for unfunded policy pledges. My own party ran on a manifesto in the 2024 general election which committed to around £80 billion in deficit spending, carrying with it the irresponsible risk of inflation at a time when prices are already hurting average quality of life.
This particular criticism can be addressed by simply moderating the argument for the extent of fiscal expansionism MMT enables. Other criticisms, however, cannot be accommodated nearly as easily. The next problem with the theory is a myopic focus on the government as the only relevant agent of fiscal policy in states with monetary sovereignty. Suspending the independence of a national bank would spook markets and go down poorly with voters. Good luck selling tax rises as an alternative to interest rate hikes in holding down inflation to the electorate; the ‘tax raid’ headlines practically write themselves. But perhaps the biggest problem with MMT’s focus on the government is its apparent ignorance to how big changes in monetary policy affect markets. Government bonds and mortgage rates are impacted heavily by monetary policy, which is something Liz Truss and Kwasi Kwarteng had to learn the hard way. Whether its tens of billions in unfunded tax cuts, or similarly large deficits to fund public spending, the impact on the economy and the stability of the government would be largely the same.
Inducing market panic is not necessarily the fault of MMT itself, but of how markets and business leaders perceive it. Even if completely viable in theory, MMT would not work in practice as that it is not viewed as credible by key stakeholders. Investors would take one look at a spending unmatched by taxation to the tune of tens of billions of Pounds and the government’s assurance that debt would be paid off via creating new money, and elect not to invest. Such an economy would be perceived as unpredictable and overly interventionist, which are not the conditions investors trust when looking for a return on their investment. Given the interdependence of economies in today’s globalised world, the capital flight induced by the adoption of MMT-style monetary reforms would be a disaster for any country adopting them.
I can already anticipate my more left-wing readers scoffing at this concern for investment. Should our concern not be with the standard of living for working people rather than the wealthy elite? Why not replace private investment with public investment made possible by MMT? What this proposals amounts to is, in essence, the pivot from market capitalism to a command economy. Which, depending on your persuasion, may or may not be desirable. Regardless of what one thinks about the principles underlying such an economy, it certainly would not work in today’s economic climate. Modern economies are complex and interdependent on those of other nations, which makes accounting for every precise incentive and consumer demand in central planning virtually impossible. Plus, the global nature of contemporary capitalism means the British state is limited in what it can actually do, as many decisions which affect British workers are made beyond our jurisdiction. Nor is withdrawing from international commerce in a huff plausible, as doing so would harm consumer choice and endanger millions of jobs. On a humanitarian angle, MMT risks dramatically decreasing the standard of living for most, not improving it.
Yet the biggest problem with MMT has nothing to do with its fiscal irresponsibility, but its refusal to directly confront any of the structural problems with contemporary capitalism. Being Keynesian in origin, it says nothing about the appropriation of labour or asymmetry in property ownership at the micro-economic scale. On this basis, it is rather odd that many of its main proponents self-identify as socialists or socialist-adjacent. Even if one likes MMT, it can only provide a blueprint for the first stages of a broader transition to socialism that it does not set up particularly well. Rather than harnessing the productive power of capitalism to create the material conditions necessary to support socialism, as orthodox Marxism advocates, MMT would stunt this growth. The theory is simultaneously far too radical and nowhere near radical enough, marrying the worst elements of a command economy and oligarchical capitalism into an incoherent mess.
III: Geosocialism as an Alternative
If I feel so strongly about MMT’s deficiencies, then comes the question of whether I have an alternative which fulfils the role of improving quality of life in the short to medium term. And I believe I do. If the problems with MMT are fiscal expansionism and a lack of concern for ownership, then an inverse position of fiscal responsibility and egalitarianism of ownership is worth exploring. I have taken to calling this position (or at least a version of it) geosocialism, and believe it should inform the basis of green political economy.
Being a synthetic position, geosocialism has two component parts. The first, geoism, should be familiar to any of you who have read my earlier article on the topic. In short, geoism is an economic theory advocating for the egalitarian distribution of natural wealth via a tax on the unimproved value of the land (LVT). This is paired with a market economy and free trade, retaining the profit motive and thus a rationale for private investment. The idea, as articulated by Henry George among others, is that labourers are entitled to what they produce, whereas the natural wealth created by no one should be owned in common.
There are a number of advantages to this approach, outlined in more detail in my earlier article. But the most significant vis-à-vis MMT is its credibility as a reformist position, as geoism would work with rather than against contemporary capitalism. Where MMT would not be trusted by the market, geoism is supported by economists across the political spectrum. This includes Nobel Laureates like Joseph Stiglitz and William Vickrey, as well as (surprisingly) Austrian economist Fred Foldvary and Chicago economist Milton Friedman. In cutting other taxes, such as corporation tax and business rates, the possibility of profit retains an incentive for investment which MMT would alienate. Plus, the progressive nature and efficiency of LVT in lieu of its fewer negative externalities and a higher burden on wealthy landowners complements governments seeking to spend within their means. By creating a mechanism to fund social programs without fiscal expansionism, geoism effectively renders MMT obsolete.
On its own, however, geoism fails to address all structural economic problems. Beyond inegalitarian land ownership, this framework is powerless to confront modern capitalism. Which is why a reconciliation with socialism is required. This does not immediately seem to be the most natural partnership; beyond a wealth tax on land, geoism and socialism seem fundamentally contrary to each other. Yet when we distil socialism down to its essence, the common ownership of enterprise, there are versions of a geoist socialism which could work. Specifically, forms of socialism which preserve market mechanisms and achieve common ownership via mutualisation. This form of socialism, discussed as co-operatism by this blog’s co-editor, would take the step geoism alone refuses to make and establish true economic democracy through worker and consumer co-operatives.
IV: Conclusion
Geosocialism, the union of geoist land value taxation and co-operative enterprise ownership, thus represents a more plausible and more viable economic theory for green movements that MMT. Given that greens are committed to parliamentarism and thus reformism, it will be necessary to put forward a progressive platform which is simultaneously radical enough to help and also plausible enough to actually happen. MMT is neither, failing to address the fundamental structural problems of capitalism while also unable to offer practical first steps which the broader economy would trust. Basically, Zack Polanski should be listening less to Richard Murphy and more to Joseph Stiglitz. We as a party need policy rooted in credible economics, not populist slogans with no deeper substance.
This is already working wonders for the German Greens, who have recently implemented a land value tax in the German state of Baden-Württemberg. This dynamic system, allowing localities to set the percentage of land value they wish to be taxed, is one of the largest implementations of geoist principles of its kind. We English and Welsh Greens should take note. If this is working for them, then why shy away from it ourselves?

Leave a Reply